Jen McCreight just got a fun comment on an old blog post that she reposted for our amusement. It is a wonderful little thing of insanity. I decided to play with it.
The comment by WanTan Silo is in blue.
PZ’s reputation as a reasonable scientist is definitely tarnished by the way he sets aside reason in exchange for chivalry.
‘PZ’ here is PZ Myers, a professor of biology and a skeptic and atheist blogger. He’s also a feminist. Jen was referring to a post by him about how stereotyping hurts women.
Let’s look up the word ‘chivalry’ for starters. According to Wikipedia:
The Knight’s Code of Chivalry was a moral system that stated all knights should protect others who can not protect themselves, such as widows, children, and elders.
In other words. PZ Myers is defending women because women cannot defend themselves. We are so helpless, right? Not like women took action and – you know – came up with feminism or anything. 1 misogyny point.
… –i.e. the defense of women and femininity even when it’s clear that the other sex really deserves the defense.
Instead he should defend the real under-privileged sex, the men. Reminds me of the MRA’s attempt to co-opt The Second Sex. 1 MRA point.
He likely rationalizes this with a conspiracy theory called “patriarchy” …
The patriarchy is no conspiracy theory. Again, we go to Wikipedia because it’s easy, and it’s 1:30 AM and I’m lazy:
Patriarchy is a social system in which the male acts as the primary authority figure central to social organization, and where fathers hold authority over women, children, and property.
This is the case in many parts of society, and in complete effect in a number of countries. It is not a conspiracy theory, because it is not even a conspiracy. It is done in the open and assumed as the right thing to do by many. Denial of this fact will award him with another 3 MRA points.
… wherein women are infantilized and treated as robots with no free will.
Women are neither treated like infants, nor without free will by the patriarchy. Women are treated as inferior and of less value. The so-called ‘conspiracy theory’ does not demand such claims, that is a strawman; an exaggeration to try to present the concept of the patriarchy in feminism as unreasonable. The patriarchy, as defined above, doesn’t actually depend on any of these views of women other than non-inclusion. 1 MRA point.
It’s quite funny how someone can be so rational in some areas but completely credulous when it comes to patriarchy “theory”.
To make that judgement one need to first have a clue what ‘patriarchy theory’ is. 1 ignorance point.
I really do think that men like him behave this way because of deep, evolutionary pressure to compete with other males for the favor of females.
PZ Myers is married. So even if that was true, it wouldn’t be relevant. In any case, suggesting people who care about human rights do so only to get sex, implying the men are simple minded and the women easily fooled, is both misandrist and misogynistic. 1 misogyny point, 1 misandry point.
It’s not impossible, that’s for sure. It would be difficult to prove but, it makes perfect sense and is completely logical. I mean, those who didn’t behave in a sycophantic manner towards women would almost certainly not have reproduced in numbers as abundant as their competitors, right?
This is cute. He suddenly gets a microscopic influx of critical thought and finds it necessary to actually consider that what he just said could be wrong. It doesn’t last …
I’m not evolutionary biologist, but the idea at least makes sense.
He acknowledges he doesn’t have the faintest clue what he’s talking about, but it makes sense to him, so it must be true. Nature is misogynistic, nature determines what’s right or wrong, human ethics is irrelevant. Is that it?
I’m no biologist either, but I’ve seen the sexual selection argument abused numerous times to justify sexism. Not as often as quantum mechanics is in woo-medicine, but that one is hard to beat anyway …
I can’t be arsed to sum up the points, but they can be exchanged for exactly 1 million dumb-arguments-on-the-internet points.
In any case, I need some sleep. Good night!